Contact Us

We will create an outstanding closing experience
for you and your client…each and every time!
If you don’t agree, let us know, and we will make it right.


Our Story

Integrity, efficiency and enthusiasm makes John Bethell Title the best choice for you when it comes to title services in the Bloomington area. Our driving force is YOU. Each closing is a team effort, and you are the star player. Our open environment makes your transaction the best we have done…so far. Whether it’s a digital or traditional process, your experience with “A-Team of B-Town” will be stress free, and attention to detail is the key. What’s best for you is what we do…every time.

We specialize in insured closings, title insurance policies,
loan policies, and searches.

What our clients say

Just closed on our new house yesterday. My husband is in the military and deployed to the Middle East. I called and asked if they would be able to handle closing our property under these conditions, they said yes and they were correct! They did a phenomenal job! Lexi our pre closer and Kelli our closer were wonderful. They communicated with me promptly every time, they handled all regular closing activities and handled POA’s and helped us with our lender which was horrible. Kelli and Lexi went out of their way to help me push the lender to do work and respond. With all the trouble we had from the lender, the John Bethell team still closed on time!

We worked with Amy and the John Bethell Title Co. twice in the last several months. I cannot recall working with an individual and/or company that was as professional and responsive as these folks. Every email and call was returned promptly and all our questions were answered and explained clearly. The second closing started with a different title co. (requested by the buyer) but after two weeks of nothing and 10 days with our emails unanswered, we switched over to Amy/Bethell and she had it done in 2 days!!!!

I have worked in the real estate industry for over 25 years in commercial property development. I have dealt with dozens of closings with title agencies. This is by far the best one I’ve ever dealt with. The most streamlined. The most friendly. And the least contentious closing of any that I’ve ever experienced.

The closing process for our new home in Bloomington IN with Bethell was very smooth from start to finish. Preparatory steps went smoothly ahead of the closing date. Rebecca handled the closing documents and signing actions smoothly and professionally. A job well done by John Bethell and Rebecca Spencer!! Thank You All.

Online Ordering Tool

Ordering title work from John Bethell Title Company, Inc. couldn’t be any easier. Just follow our simple guide, and you’re on your way. We provide info for REALTORS, Lenders, and Sellers.



© 2022 John Bethell Title Company